The secret is out on McCall, Idaho. Almost anyone who visits McCall, located just two hours north of Boise, has toyed with the idea of moving there. Situated on the shores of Payette Lake in the Idaho Rockies, McCall offers idyllic scenery, year-round recreation, and small-town charm.

If you’re thinking about relocating to McCall or buying a second home in the area, you won’t be disappointed. While the real estate market has seen strong demand, much like the rest of Idaho, the area offers plenty of options.

Did you know we are members of the Mountain MLS and help buyers and sellers in the McCall area?

As a Boise native and regular visitor to the McCall area, Katie McFerrin brings an extensive knowledge of the market to the table. If you’ve been thinking about making a move to McCall, the McFerrin Real Estate team is here to help.

Buying Real Estate in McCall & Donnelly

High Demand, Higher Prices

Prices for houses in McCall have exploded in recent years. With the rise of remote workers and the influx of out-of-state buyers, many buyers who have recently moved to the Treasure Valley are looking to the McCall area for a second home.

The data backs up this trend. The rapid growth of Boise has spilled over to McCall where home sales increased 23% in 2020 according to the Idaho Statesman. Many homeowners have converted their properties into AirBnBs to take advantage of the demand.

According to Realtor.com, the median listing price for homes in McCall is $650,000 with a median price per square foot of $391. Nearby towns Cascade and Donnelly paint a similar picture. The median listing home price in Cascade is $482,500 and $795,000 in Donnelly.

Luxury Mountain Homes

For luxury buyers, the McCall area boasts a variety of high-end homes. Homes on or around Payette Lake are in high demand with limited properties available.

Other popular areas include the Whitetail Club and King’s Pines Estates areas that offer private resort living at the award-winning Whitetail Golf Course. Another option in the McCall area is to buy new construction or even build a custom home.

Tamarack Resort

Many homeowners looking in the McCall area fall head over heels for the Tamarack Resort located near Donnelly on Cascade Lake. America’s newest all-season resort offers homeowners direct access to nature with a 3,600-acre backyard available to homeowners.

Real estate options in Tamarack include ski-in/ski-out condominiums, townhouses, cottages, and chalets nestled among the trails. Owning a home in the Tamarack Resort gives you an unparalleled and convenient luxury lifestyle.

Have Questions About McCall?

If you’re interested in visiting McCall or considering homes in the McCall area, the team at McFerrin Real Estate has a wide range of opportunities available to you.

Together, we can answer any questions you may have and strategize a plan to get you the home of your dreams. As a luxury real estate and relocation specialist, Katie McFerrin and her team bring a highly-personalized experience to every transaction. Call us at (208) 921-0334 or visit our website www.mcferrinrealestate.com for more information.

McCall Activities Guide

McCall is a great place to spend time with your family any season of the year. The mountain resort town is one of the hottest destinations for anyone looking for the best of Idaho’s outdoorsy lifestyle.

Outdoor Recreation

During the summer months, McCall offers plenty to do in the great outdoors. You can go paddle-boarding on Payette Lake, whitewater rafting on the Payette River, or hike the Payette National Forest.

If you like to hit the snow, the McCall area is the perfect place to find what you’re looking for. With three ski resorts -- Tamarack Resort, Little Ski Hill, and Brundage Mountain -- close to town, you can find whatever terrain you’re looking for.

Downtown McCall

Any trip to the area should include a visit to downtown McCall. The heart of the city welcomes first-time arrivals and provides a place for the community to gather. The downtown has shops, restaurants, and entertainment. If you have time, make sure to stop by the always popular Ice Cream Alley or lace up the skates for ice skating at the Manchester Ice Center.

Burgdorf Hot Springs

If you’re looking to relax, the Burgdorf Hot Springs is a perfect mountain getaway. The rustic retreat is located 32 miles north of McCall and offers historic cabins for rent. Burgdorf has limited access during the winter months so we suggest you make a reservation before you go.

Ponderosa State Park

Right outside downtown McCall, Ponderosa State Park is an outdoor playground with spectacular views of the lake. Visitors can hike, picnic, cycle, mountain bike, play volleyball and horseshoes, swim, fish, and watch for wildlife. When it snows, snowshoeing and cross-country skiing are popular activities. For overnight stays, the park offers campsites and cabins.

Shore Lodge

On the shores of the Payette sits the upscale Shore Lodge. Walking distance from downtown McCall, the hotel features special amenities with three dining locations, a full-service salon and spa, and shuttles to local ski resorts. If you stay during the summer you have access to water and boat rentals right outside your room.